Preservation edition · October 3, 2026 · Geekenstein Editorial
Historical source: Jake Petersen, March 16, 2013. This edition contains a newly written, condensed account of the original coverage, with historical opinions attributed to their author. It is not the original article or a new firsthand review.
The product and its historical verdict
Duel Decks: Sorin vs. Tibalt paired a white-black Sorin deck with a black-red Tibalt deck. Each contained 60 cards. The product released on March 15, 2013. Geekenstein’s review listed a launch MSRP of $19.99; that is a historical price, not an offer available today.
What Jake Petersen’s review concluded
Petersen’s assessment separated the head-to-head experience from the usefulness of the reprints. His reported playtesting favored Sorin: Tibalt could apply early pressure, but struggled when its hand emptied and Sorin established larger creatures, tokens and life gain. He criticized the uneven matchup while still recommending the package as a source of cards for other decks. The recovered text explicitly awarded 4 out of 5. That is his historical score, not a newly tested Geekenstein rating.
Reading the matchup today
The following is analysis of the printed lists, not a new playtest result. Sorin has 25 lands and several ways to create multiple creatures from one card. Tibalt has 24 lands, direct damage and graveyard reuse. Those different plans make sequencing matter: an aggressive opening and a stable board are different kinds of advantage. Sorin’s token plan also means that trading one removal spell for one small creature may not solve Tibalt’s problem.
A useful test for two players
Start with the unmodified lists below, use the same mulligan rule throughout, swap decks and alternate who plays first. Record opening hands, missed land drops, decisive cards and wins for each seat. A handful of games can expose play patterns, but cannot establish a reliable matchup percentage. Keep any house-rule changes separate from results for the factory lists.
Physical Duel Decks and Forge are different contexts
The SlightlyMagic discussion that linked to this review concerned relative difficulty and balance in Forge Quest. A software implementation, Quest rewards or modified decks can change that experience. The physical lists and Petersen’s reported tabletop result should not be represented as a measured win rate for Forge.
Collector checks
For an opened copy, count each deck separately and match quantities against the lists. Identify the DDK printing rather than assuming another printing of a card is the same collectible. Check condition and whether any cards were substituted. Historical comments about Standard play or reprint value describe 2013; verify present format legality separately. No current market price or investment return is claimed here.
Related collecting tools
If you also collect games such as Pokémon, Disney Lorcana or ONE PIECE, KLXCards’ card library helps distinguish exact printings. Its current catalog is separate from this historical Magic product reference.
Original 60-card decklists
Quantities below describe the factory decks. Basic-land quantities count toward the 60 cards. Tokens are separate from the main deck.
Sorin — 60 cards
Lands
- 2 × Evolving Wilds
- 9 × Plains
- 12 × Swamp
- 2 × Tainted Field
Creatures
- 1 × Bloodrage Vampire
- 1 × Butcher of Malakir
- 1 × Child of Night
- 2 × Doomed Traveler
- 2 × Duskhunter Bat
- 1 × Fiend Hunter
- 1 × Gatekeeper of Malakir
- 1 × Mausoleum Guard
- 1 × Mesmeric Fiend
- 1 × Phantom General
- 1 × Revenant Patriarch
- 1 × Sengir Vampire
- 1 × Twilight Drover
- 1 × Vampire Lacerator
- 1 × Vampire Nighthawk
- 1 × Vampire Outcasts
- 1 × Wall of Omens
Instants
- 1 × Mortify
- 1 × Sorin’s Thirst
- 1 × Unmake
- 1 × Urge to Feed
- 1 × Vampire’s Bite
- 1 × Zealous Persecution
Sorceries
- 1 × Absorb Vis
- 1 × Ancient Craving
- 1 × Death Grasp
- 1 × Decompose
- 1 × Lingering Souls
- 2 × Spectral Procession
Enchantments
- 1 × Field of Souls
- 1 × Mark of the Vampire
Planeswalkers
- 1 × Sorin, Lord of Innistrad
Tibalt — 60 cards
Lands
- 2 × Akoum Refuge
- 14 × Mountain
- 2 × Rakdos Carnarium
- 6 × Swamp
Creatures
- 2 × Ashmouth Hound
- 1 × Coal Stoker
- 1 × Corpse Connoisseur
- 1 × Gang of Devils
- 1 × Goblin Arsonist
- 1 × Hellrider
- 2 × Hellspark Elemental
- 1 × Lavaborn Muse
- 1 × Mad Prophet
- 1 × Reassembling Skeleton
- 1 × Scorched Rusalka
- 1 × Scourge Devil
- 1 × Shambling Remains
- 1 × Skirsdag Cultist
- 2 × Vithian Stinger
Instants
- 1 × Blazing Salvo
- 1 × Flame Javelin
- 1 × Geistflame
- 1 × Strangling Soot
- 1 × Terminate
Sorceries
- 1 × Blightning
- 1 × Breaking Point
- 2 × Browbeat
- 1 × Bump in the Night
- 1 × Devil’s Play
- 1 × Faithless Looting
- 1 × Flame Slash
- 1 × Pyroclasm
- 1 × Recoup
- 1 × Torrent of Souls
Enchantments
Planeswalkers
- 1 × Tibalt, the Fiend-Blooded
Sources and further reading
Preservation source and omissions
The historical article container was recovered from a Common Crawl capture dated 2017-08-20. The full original prose, author biography, advertisements and third-party media are not republished. Archive availability alone does not grant reuse rights. The original publication date is shown only where verified.
Common Crawl source file (compressed archive record; capture timestamp 20170820225121).
Browse Geekenstein · About this edition and corrections